How to decide what to grow on your allotment and suggestions for alternatives to try (2024)

Rather than growing the same old crops year after year, why not rethink what deserves the time and space and make our fruit and veg work a little harder to earn their place on the plot

An allotment doesn’t have to be the traditional space we all think of, it can also be a small garden or even a balcony.If you’ve just got your first allotment and wondering what you should grow, or if you’re an old hand wanting a change, with all the options of fruit and veg and all their different varieties,it can be difficult to know where to start.

The popularity of allotments has surged and waned since the ‘Dig for Victory’ campaign of the Second World War, but looking at today’s allotment sites, you’d be forgiven for thinking that little has changed in the past 80 years when it comes to what we chose to grow.

Allotment maths

With the cost of living crisis making it all the more important that gardeners get the most out of their investment ofeffort, cost and space, perhaps it’s time to take a different approach. When making a list of possible crops, try to consider the factors below and assign a positive or negative value.

Do I like to eat it?

Rather than eating what you grow, turn the concept on its head and grow what you eat. When you get out your seed catalogues this autumn, ask yourself, would you cook it if you didn’tgrow it?

The ultimate allotment stalwart must be the humble runner bean, and with good reason. Its gorgeous flowers quickly scramble up supports and it requires little effort for the masses of fruit it provides. However, is it really tastier than its cousin the french bean? A quick search for runner bean recipes on the BBC’s Good Food website comes up with 44 results. The same for green beans produces 3,086.

Swap - If you love growing potatoes, try – Fir Apple, delicious nutty flavour, very difficult to get in the shops.

While our culinary tastes have changed, what we grow hasn’t altered much since the 1950s. Given the nation’s most popular takeaway meals include Japanese, Indian and Mexican cuisine,why aren’t coriander and lemongrass part of our kitchen gardens and why aren’t tomatillos and edamame more common crops?

Is it difficult to grow?

Tomatoes are one of the most popular grow your own crops, they are delicious and can be grown in a container, or even a hanging basket if you don’t have a garden. However they can be demanding, some varieties require support, possibly a greenhouse, as well as regular pinching out, watering and feeding. Tomatoes are also susceptible to many various pests and diseases. Consider saving time and effort by growing only the types that are expensive to buy such as cherry, or rare heritage varieties larger tomatoes and passata are inexpensive, readily available and often come from , if not the UK, Europe.

Is it expensive or difficult to buy?

Beetroot has long been an allotment favourite as it’s very easy to grow, however it also has the added benefit of providing a double crop. Harvest the leaves fora delicious salad and then dig up the roots to be roasted, pickled or stored. Beetroot can also be quite hard to find in the shops so if you enjoy the taste and health boosting veg, they are well worth a spot on the plot.

Can I save on food miles?

The best way to cut down the food miles on your plate is to eat seasonally and grow as much of your own food as possible. Fruit is often shipped from all over the world, out of season apples can come from as far away as New Zealand. If you have an apple tree and somewhere to store your harvest, it is possible to be eating home-grown all year round.

Swap – If you love the taste of broccoli, why not grow the more expensivepurple sprouting broccoli rather than calabrise?

Shop-bought fruit is also more likely than veg to be wrapped in plastic packaging and sprayed with chemicals. All good reasons to devote part of your plot to growing berries and pomes.

The X-factor

Some things are just fun to grow, even if they don’t add up on paper. If you love eating peas straight from the pod on a warm summer day, no amount of information about modern farming freezing processes ensuring freshness will stop you from growing them yourself.

Swap – Try growing cut-and-come-again leaves rather than heads of lettuce, for a low effort crop you can harvest for longer.

Growing carrots which need protecting against carrot-root fly, is illogical when you consider how cheap and plentiful British-grown carrots are to buy. Yet carrots continue to be one of the most popular seeds sold, particularly among children who love the magic of pulling up their golden treat. Always grow what you love, but maybe try to make some room for something different this year.